5439 E Carefree Hwy, Cave Creek, AZ 85331

Retail · Cave Creek · Phoenix metro, AZ

One of 186 reachable retail buildings in Cave Creek. Larger than 29% of retail buildings in Cave Creek (median 7,402 SF), derived from assessor records.

County gross building area
4,580 SF, Maricopa County Assessor
Lot size
94,888 SF, Maricopa County Assessor
Year built
1999, Maricopa County Assessor
Stories
1, Maricopa County Assessor
Buildings on parcel
2, Maricopa County Assessor
Predominant use
Convenience Store With Fuel Dispensin, Maricopa County Assessor
Assessed value
$3,782,135, per the Maricopa County Assessor (not a market appraisal)
Assessed value per building SF
$825.79/SF, derived from assessor records
Building area / lot
0.05, derived from assessor records
Vintage
1990s vintage
County use code
CONVENIENCE STORE WITH FUEL DISPENSIN

Nearby comparable buildings

Same building type, by distance. Assessor facts only; not an opinion of value.

Want to talk to the owner? makeme1031 delivers a private letter directly to the owner of record. We never publish the owner's identity or address.

Own this building?

Claim privately

Claiming is for you. Your mailing address is never shown; no offer reaches you unless you opt in.

Claimed owners can confirm facts, watch the estimate, and decide whether to reply.

Received a letter about this building? It came from a real buyer through makeme1031; claiming is how you reply privately, on your terms.

Claimed owners also get Portfolio Pulse: a monthly email tracking this building's value.

Claim or manage this building

Sale history and market context

MakeMe Estimate: $4.79M (estimated market value), with a likely range of $3.83M to $5.68M (half of recent verified sales in this segment landed inside that range). Computed as the county's full cash value of $3,782,135 times a 1.27 market ratio, measured from 3891 verified arm's-length sale prices vs county values (retail sales in Cave Creek, through 2026-06-29). Not an appraisal. How this estimate works.

lower confidence: 6 comparable sales within 3 miles; nearest 0.8 mi. This property type carries wider measured error; treat the estimate as a starting point. Comparable-sale caveat: the estimate is well above (more than 3x apart from) the $310.25/SF median of the shown comparable sales.

Comparable sales used as evidence

Recorded arm's-length sales of similar buildings nearby; nearer and more recent sales rank first. The strongest 5 of 6 nearby verified sales are shown. Buyer and seller names are withheld. Get this data via API.

Market context: Retail in Cave Creek

median verified sale $310.25/SF over the trailing 24 months; 5 sales in the last 12 months and 8 in 24 (newest verified sale 2026-03); the middle 80% of recent sales traded at 0.69x to 2.64x their county full cash value, median 1.28x (8 sales with usable county values).

  • 2022: $299.02/SF median (6 sales)
  • 2023: $248.96/SF median (9 sales)
  • 2025: $310.25/SF median (4 sales)

This estimate sits at 1.27x county full cash value, the 50th percentile of those recent sale premiums.

Computed from 69 verified arm's-length sales in Maricopa County public records (8 in the trailing 24 months). Free public records. Not an appraisal.

Value over time

$0$2M$4M$6M20262027$4.79M$3.78MCounty assessed valueMakeMe Estimate range

Dark line: county assessed value per Maricopa County tax rolls. Blue line: our estimate; dashed years are a modeled backcast built from recorded arm's-length sales in the building's segment, not estimates published at the time, and years without enough sales stay unmodeled. The shaded range is the model's measured error band; about half of verified sales in the segment land inside it. Not an appraisal. How this estimate works.

Land, site, and value history

Assessed value moved from $3,547,631 (2026) to $3,782,135 (2027), up 7% over 1 years, per county tax rolls. The 2027 roll splits $3,782,135 into $2,383,100 land and $1,399,035 improvements.